You see flashing lights ahead and traffic slowing to a crawl. Officers wave drivers through a checkpoint, stopping some vehicles while others pass freely. Can police legally stop your car without a reason to suspect you of anything?
What Texas law says about sobriety checkpoints
In Holt v. State, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals held that, under the Fourth Amendment, sobriety checkpoints must be authorized by a statewide policy established by a politically accountable governing body. Without that authorization, a sobriety checkpoint is unconstitutional. The court did not rule on whether the checkpoint also violated the Texas Constitution. Texas has no statewide policy allowing sobriety checkpoints for DWI enforcement.
For a standard traffic stop, officers generally need reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation or criminal activity before stopping your car. Because Texas does not allow sobriety checkpoints, officers cannot pull you over just to check whether you are driving while intoxicated.
How are checkpoints different from other stops?
Police can run other types of checkpoints. License and insurance checkpoints may be allowed if the main purpose is checking for valid licenses and insurance rather than investigating crime. Federally authorized Border Patrol checkpoints are another exception.
A regular traffic stop works differently. Officers must point to specific facts that suggest a traffic violation or criminal activity. Weaving between lanes, speeding or failing to signal can justify pulling you over. To turn a traffic stop into a DWI investigation, officers generally need a reason to suspect intoxication. Chemical testing has its own legal requirements. A DWI defense attorney can review whether officers had a lawful basis to stop you and investigate further.
What protections apply during unlawful stops?
If police violated your rights during a traffic stop, a court may block that evidence from being used against you. This is called the exclusionary rule. Whether it applies depends on the facts of your stop and the legal issues involved.
Getting legal help after a traffic stop
If you were stopped in McKinney, elsewhere in Collin County or in the Dallas area, the details of that stop may affect your options. A criminal defense attorney can review whether officers followed proper procedures and whether the evidence against you can be challenged.
